Buying a new toy for Miya Angel

Have you ever bought a new toy for the pup only to discover she likes the "old" one better? I experienced that today. I came home with a new fluffy toy and to my surprise when I said "lets play" she went looking for the old one.  She sniffed the new one and walked away from it. When she found "Oh No (Bill)" she brought it to me, ears up as to say "lets play"! So I had to distract her, take up Bill and proceed to play with her with the new one (no name as of yet). She pick it up a couple times but kept dropping it to "search" for Oh No! Bill.  I found this amazing! So I showed her Oh No! Bill and she got all excited! Well the plan is to take Oh No! Bill and put him to rest (for a little while anyway, he needs much repair-torn left arm) and leave the new teddy out for her tomorrow and she'll start fresh! Yeah, that's how we'll get her to forget him. Any suggestions?